Navigating the Electric Avenue: A Strategic Perspective on 4W EV Adoption in Delhi and Karnataka

EV Policy: Reality vs. Intent

In the bustling streets of Delhi and Karnataka, the electric vehicle (EV) revolution is quietly unfolding, albeit at a pace that warrants a closer examination. As pioneers in electrifying mobility across India, both states have embarked on a journey, steering towards a future where EVs are not just an alternative but a predominant choice for new buyers. However, the road to electrification, particularly in the four-wheeler segment, has been anything but smooth.

Delhi, with its aggressive incentive strategy, and Karnataka, with a more subdued approach, have both encountered similar roadblocks in their pursuit of electrifying the four-wheeler market. Despite their efforts, most EV registrations in these states are confined to two-wheelers, revealing a stark contrast between policy intentions and on-ground reality.

Source: Analysis of State Electric Vehicle Policies and Their Impact on Climate Trend

Divergent Policy Approaches, Similar Inefficacies

Delhi’s EV policy, introduced in 2019, was lauded for its comprehensive approach, intertwining FAME and state-sponsored direct subsidies, road tax, and registration fee exemptions, alongside incentives on electricity tariffs. On the other hand, Karnataka, despite having a two-year head start with its EV policy introduced in 2017, adopted a softer stance, providing exemptions on road taxes and registration fees, coupled with FAME and electricity tariff benefits for EV charging.

The divergence in policy approaches, however, has not translated into a significant difference in four-wheeler EV adoption between the two states. This brings us to a pivotal question: What impedes the transition from internal combustion engines to EVs, especially in the four-wheeler segment?

Boosting EV Adoption: Challenges & Solutions

In 2023, a study illuminated that 70% of car consumers in tier I cities, including Delhi and Bangalore, were inclined towards EVs, citing environmental impact, lower ownership cost, and reduced engine noise. However, this willingness is yet to mirror in actual purchase decisions, largely attributed to the prevailing “EV as my second vehicle” mindset among consumers. As we delve more deeply into the strategic implications of these findings, it becomes imperative to address the challenges and recalibrate policies to align with consumer behavior and market dynamics. Both states, while leading the charge in EV mobility, need to bridge the gap between consumer perception, infrastructure, and policy to drive the adoption of four-wheeler EVs.

Addressing these challenges necessitates a multi-faceted approach. Firstly, targeted campaigns must be implemented to shift consumer perception and encourage first-time car buyers to opt for EVs. If we look into the market, the cheapest electric car costs INR 9 lakh (USD 10,800), and the cheapest ICE car costs INR 4-5 lakh (USD 4,800-6,000). Therefore, enhancing the availability and accessibility of financing options for potential EV buyers is essential. Traditional auto-financing institutions often hesitate to offer loans for EVs due to their higher upfront costs and uncertainties regarding their resale value and battery life. This reluctance can be a significant barrier for consumers, especially in a price-sensitive market like India. To tackle this, both Delhi and Karnataka could explore partnerships with banks and non-banking financial companies (NBFCs) to introduce attractive financing schemes with lower interest rates and longer tenures specifically for EVs. For instance, the State Bank of India (SBI) has already launched a 'Green Car Loan' offering lower interest rates for electric vehicles, which could serve as a model for other financial institutions. Such initiatives could make EVs more affordable and reduce the financial burden on consumers, thereby accelerating the transition to electric mobility. Secondly, investing in developing a robust charging infrastructure and facilitating easier access to charging stations is crucial to alleviate range anxiety among potential EV buyers. Currently, there is only 2,500 charging station in Delhi against its 2022-25 plan to establish 18,000 charging station. Similarly, Karnataka is way behind Delhi, having only 736 charging stations and planning to expand it to 1,000 in the near future,. Thirdly, the perceived uncertainty about the long-term reliability, maintenance costs, and resale value of EVs poses a significant psychological barrier to their adoption. Consumers are accustomed to the known maintenance regimes and the established resale value of ICE vehicles. In contrast, the nascent EV market in India lacks a historical record to assure potential buyers of the longevity and post-ownership value of their investment. To address these concerns, state governments can collaborate with manufacturers to provide extended warranties, guaranteed buy-back programs, and transparent maintenance guidelines. For example, some manufacturers now offer warranties that cover the EV battery - a component that accounts for a significant portion of the vehicle's cost—for up to eight years. Additionally, creating a database of resale transactions for EVs could help establish a trusted benchmark for their resale value. These measures could help mitigate the financial risks associated with EV ownership and instill greater confidence among consumers. (Give me a third reason please, 2 doesn’t seem enough, 3 is better)

Conclusion

In conclusion, the journey towards a sustainable and electrified future in Delhi and Karnataka is a testament to the ambitious vision of these states. Despite the well-intentioned policies and the growing consumer interest in electric vehicles, the adoption of four-wheeler EVs remains a complex challenge that requires a strategic and multi-pronged approach. The gap between the enthusiasm for EVs and their actual purchase underscores the need for a recalibration of strategies that align with consumer expectations, financial realities, and infrastructural readiness.

To truly accelerate the shift towards electric mobility, it is crucial to address the financial, psychological, and infrastructural barriers that consumers face. Initiatives like targeted financial schemes, robust charging infrastructure, and reassurances on the longevity and resale value of EVs are not just policy measures but essential catalysts for change. The efforts of Delhi and Karnataka in this direction, although commendable, must be amplified and supported by collaborative efforts between the government, financial institutions, and the automotive industry.

As we stand at the cusp of an EV revolution, it is imperative for stakeholders to foster an ecosystem that not only promotes electric vehicles as a viable and preferred option but also reassures consumers of their practicality and long-term benefits. The path to a greener and cleaner future is paved with challenges, but with persistent efforts and strategic policymaking, Delhi and Karnataka can lead by example and set a benchmark for other regions to follow. The electric avenue is not just a road less traveled but a journey towards innovation, sustainability, and a better tomorrow for all.

Asha & Company is a Tokyo-headquartered Kathmandu-based market research and consulting firm. We can be the intelligence partner for your growth in Asia. We offer Intelligence products, Market Reports, and Insights, Consumer and Expert interviews, and Sales support. Mail to [email protected] for any queries or visit www.asha.inc.